First off, I want to mention that I do two types of clean-up techniques on this film. Both digital and traditional; digital cleanup is done using the brush tool and Wacom tablet in flash-fairly straight-forward. This is only done on scenes that have very few drawings since I find it very time-consuming. The traditonal method is done using black pens on 23lb Chromacolour animation bond. The idea is to simulate a brush and ink which was standard in the early days of animation before the Xerox machine and the computer.
First I simply take my ruff pencil drawing and place a clean sheet of paper over it. This is totally obvious of course, but I'll mention it anyway for sake of completeness.

The next step depends on the roughness of the drawing-if it is really rough and unresolved I go over the drawing in light blue pencil on the fresh sheet of paper, refining the drawing. I didn't do that step for this particular drawing since it is tight enough for me to see all the shapes clearly.

Next I start inking in the drawing. I always start with the main largest shapes first. Large forms get the thickest lines usually. This helps to give weight and unity to the form-in this case, the head. Also, I try to make sure that the lines are more or less the same weight and define the form (in other words if I was to continue the lines where they are overlapped by other forms they will connect up and create a closed shape.)

Next, I ink in the smaller forms. I am very concious of the angles and curves that exist in the rough pencil drawing and I try to maintain them as I ink in the form. I also try to simulate a brush line by keeping the lines tapered at the ends as well as thicker in the middle apex of the curve. Note how these shapes have generally thinner lines than the main head form.
Now I do the features. Facial features should be the most important thing in a head, so even though they may be small they should be thick enough to stand out-especially the eyes.
Now I get out my finest tipped pen (usually a Pilot Fineliner) and put in the final details. And I'm done!There are a ton of theories to doing good clean-up and I will certainly not profess to being a master at it. But mainly the ones I keep in mind are:
Maintaining a hierarchy of importance
This is done basically as I stated above, making sure that the large forms have the thicker lines and the important parts of the drawing stand out.
Preserving the essence of the rough
Flip to the rough constantly, it should look as good or better than the pencil rough. Don't tone down any angles or curves!
Keeping the lines neat and clean
Make sure the lines taper at the ends and aren't wiggly and rough looking.
Drawing the lines with flair
Be confident and try to draw curves with your wrist and in an even steady motion.
17 comments:
great tips nic, and great cleanup. robert culp is a great actor, and ishtar IS a great movie. i don't care what the world says. when do you plan to have this masterpeice done?
Thanks Tavis, I like to think of this film as my own private Ishtar...maybe I can get Bob Culp to do a guest voice?
Great Tips. I always enjoy seeing how other people work.
Beautiful! Thanks a LOT, Nick! This was a great insight! Lovely lines. I'm going to save these tips.
Hey Nick,
Beautiful work!
You mentioned using a Pilot Fineliner for the details but I was wondering what you're using for the thicker lines.
In LA we always used Eberhard-Faber Boldliners but they've been discontinued. I'm down to my last box & I need to find a good substitute.
Thanks--terrific post. These blogs are shaping up to be the ultimate art course!
So you don't actually use a brush on any of this stuff, just fake it with a fineliner?
Thats right Mike, for the thicker outlines I use a pen called a PMOP and the thinner ones are done with the Pilot Fineliner. I know that Shane Glines uses a brush and ink, but he's a genius. In my defense I have a few thousand drawings that I have to ink in so speed is the key and speed for me equals cheating and fakery.
nice! it's great to see someone break down the clean-up process. so many times it's overlooked. i've seen so many animations get f'd by a crappy ink line. it's truly an art form, nice work nick!
Thanks Jared,
I really liked your digital clean-up notes that you posted on your blog (I think it was for the Horse and Buggy models) Since reading that I've started to use some of those tips in my own Flash clean-up.
Dammit. I wish I read this before I inked my last drawing. Next time. Thanks for the H-O-T T-I-P.
Valuable information clearly conveyed! I've been doing this stuff since I was 12 and no one has ever put it a better way!
Thanks!
WOW!
Thanks for the tips Nick.
There is a really good tutorial on the WB site about line art in flash as well.
Also Toon Boom has come out with a flash importer which is awesome for more deatailed line work.
Love the stuff!!
What about the comix you did, Hot Dog Weinerscoff and Hymen, no brush?
Nope, those were still done with bendable tip markers. I probably should have used "real" comic tools, like crowquill pens and brush and ink but I just used what I had laying around..of course I DID use bristol board as opposed to paper...
Hi Nick,
Firstly this is a great blog and thanks for shedding light on the clean-up process, its always been a tricky one for me...till now.
If you have time I would really like to know how you go about you scanning your drawings then putting them into flash?
Or even a simple step by step on how you go from scanning the drawing to getting it into flash?
But if you cant be bothered I'll understand...
I can't wait to see your finished movie, it looks great.
Post a Comment